From: Dave Cornejo <dave@dogwood.com> Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.lang.smalltalk,comp.object Subject: RESULT: comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy passes 194:22 Date: Tue, 15 Aug 2000 20:49:49 GMT RESULT unmoderated group comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy passes 194:22 There were 194 YES votes and 22 NO votes, for a total of 216 valid votes. There were 2 abstentions and 2 invalid ballots. For a group to pass, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO) votes. There must also be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes. A five day discussion period follows this announcement. If no serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter. Newsgroups line: comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy Discussion of Smalltalk Language pros/cons. Voting closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 6 Aug 2000. This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions about the proposed group should be directed to the proponent. Proponent: Ian Upright <ian-news@upright.net> Votetaker: Dave Cornejo <dave@dogwood.com> RATIONALE: comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy The Smalltalk language is getting popular, and much of the traffic on comp.lang.smalltalk is related to advocacy, not technical details or questions regarding the Smalltalk language specifically. This large amount of traffic on comp.lang.smalltalk is reducing the quality of comp.lang.smalltalk and decreasing messages and interest in the newsgroup of a more technical nature. The rationale for this group is that other languages have .advocacy groups, and it seems to work well for them, and I believe the Smalltalk language now has the traffic to warrant it. CHARTER: comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy Comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy is a newgroup for debating Smalltalks' merits. Acceptable topics include (but aren't limited to): - Smalltalk's benefits and/or it's shortcomings. - How Smalltalk relates to or differs from other programming languages. - The relative merits of dynamic and static typing. It is also acceptable to crosspost to comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy when debating languages. Binary postings and advertisements are prohibited. END CHARTER. comp.lang.smalltalk.advocacy Final Voter list Voted YES ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- fzk#gams.at Franz Zahaurek LaszloZechmeister#mynd.at edw#xpoint.at Wolfgang Eder DJOHNSON#bcc.com.au Denis Johnson toivo#ucs.uwa.edu.au Toivo Pedaste gcross#netspace.net.au Graeme Cross angelov#obs.bg Angelov osvaldo#visionnaire.com.br Osvaldo Pinali Doederlein ivan.tomek#acadiau.ca Ivan Tomek basu#freenet.carleton.ca Chirantan Basu marengj#magma.ca Guy Marentette awieland#storm.ca Aaron Wieland john#tec4.ca John Eastly bsd#cs.ubc.ca Brian de Alwis dgorisek#iface.ch David Gorisek mpusnik#iface.ch Matjaz Pusnik ducasse#iam.unibe.ch ducasse stephane rieger#iam.unibe.ch Matthias Rieger tichel#iam.unibe.ch Sander Tichelaar Sjagan62#aol.com alex_arnon#atrica.com Alex Arnon morme#aveox.com Matthew Orme bruce_badger#badgerse.com Bruce Badger koschate#bigfoot.com Thomas Koschate mark.pi#bigfoot.com Mark Pirogovsky ned#bike-nomad.com Ned Konz fortin#biotools.com Scott Fortin Joern.Eyrich#brokat.com Joern Eyrich johngale#canada.com John Gale apikovsky#cincom.com Alex Pikovsky</FONT> hnowak#cincom.com Helge K. Nowak<BR> ted.bracht#coda.com Ted Bracht traymond#craftedsmalltalk.com Terry Raymond jas#cruzio.com jas imeikle#csc.com Ian Meikle daniel.schweizer#daedalos.com Daniel Schweizer Guido.Vrankar#daedalos.com Guido Vrankar jgreve#directobjects.com John Greve TimAnderson#drakemusicproject.com Tim Anderson vinay#DynamicResources.com Vinay Mutha derek.baldwin#eds.com Derek T Baldwin tgagne#efinnet.com Thomas Gagne wkohl#enron.com william kohl dmacq#erols.com Donald MacQueen julesd#erols.com Jules Dubois mcclenon#erols.com Bob McClenon yanick.beaudet#esec.com Yanick Beaudet craig#ezboard.com <FONT face=3DArial size=3D2>Craig=20 jdbell#fareselaw.com Jerry Bell Don.Rylander#FordConsultingGroup.com Don Rylander dparshan#ford.com David Parshan wilsongj#freeuk.com Geoff Wilson martiald#gemstone.com Martial Dore Benar.Kayali#de.heidelberg.com Benar Kayali bobn#home.com Bob Nemec brener#home.com Aron Brener jeffhallman#home.com Jeff Hallman long.i2s#home.com Long On patrickdlogan#home.com Patrick Logan slosher2#home.com Robert Withers swart#home.com Steve Wart chas_wade#hotmail.com Chas Wade lostpuppy3#hotmail.com Bradley Pitt nathan235#hotmail.com nathan235 suchak_jani#hotmail.com Suchak Jani toejam_78#hotmail.com Toejamn Mann warb_sucks#hotmail.com Walter A.R. Burns messick#instantiations.com Steve Messick sames#interaccess.com Samuel S. Shuster rharper#intouchsurvey.com Russell Harper</FONT></DIV> bcole#jmpstart.com William Cole tgriggs#keyww.com Griggs, Travis scline#ksc.com Steve Cline sphilp#ksc.com Samantha=20 Brian.Gridley#LibertyMutual.com Brian Gridley rapp#lmr.com L. M. Rappaport johnc#logicarts.com John Clapperton popov#macrocosmsystems.com Boris = jarober#mail.com James A. Robertson kevin.johnson#medtronic.com Kevin Johnson susan.johnson#medtronic.com Susan R. Johnson steve_burgess#merck.com Steve Burgess stevek#metacase.com Steven Kelly cdemersnews#mitchellscientific.com Christopher J. Demers phatch#mojowire.com Peter Hatch Michael_Chean#email.msn.com Michael_Chean ltrutter#my-deja.com jskurnick#ix.netcom.com Jennifer Skurnick nanji#ix.netcom.com Ravilal N. Khatri nara#netcom.com nara kszabo#nortelnetworks.com Kevin Szabo</FONT> sgelkins#nortelnetworks.com Steven Elkins blair#object-arts.com Blair=20 bower#object-arts.com Andy Bower clavender#object-arts.com Catherine Lavender spreece#object-arts.com Sally Preece kboutin#omnisig.com Karl Boutin Guido.Stet#nl.origin-it.com Stet, Guido dc#panix.com David W. Crawford squid#panix.com Yeoh Yiu Jeffrey_Jordan#progressive.com Jeff Jordan DRichter#pwrteam.com Daryl J. Richter dway#riskmetrics.com Doug Way Rjstaron#ra.rockwell.com Ray Staron seana#romaxtech.com Sean Akers gjohnson#dream.season.com Gary Johnson wdargel#shoshana.com Bill Dargel johnmci#smalltalkconsulting.com John M McIntosh clayberg#smalltalksystems.com Eric Clayberg david#speco.com David Schutt stamper#stamper.com Chris Stamper carlg#world.std.com Carl E. Gundel pearapon#ksc.th.com Pearapon Saerekul dougob#the-spa.com Doug O'Brien eguy#tisny.com Ed Trembicki-Guy andrzej.turowski#ubs.com Fred.Heida#au.unisys.com Heida, Fred xanthian#well.com Kent Paul DOlan zach#zachbaker.com Zach Baker dhz#zh.com Dieter H. Zebbedies herbert.ehrlich#basf-ag.de Herbert Ehrlich <herbert.ehrlich#web.de> Juergen.Timm#bmw.de Juergen Timm pierre.schwarz#exept.de Pierre Schwarz bguder#gmx.de Birgit Guder Ekkehard.Uthke#gmx.de Ekkehard Uthke hpreichert#interflex.de Hans-Peter Reichert list-votes#dream.kn-bremen.de Martin Schr"oder gamba#mlap.de Alfonso Gambuzza duchene#mainz.netsurf.de Horst Duch=EAne christian.haider#t-online.de Christian Haider hoelzl#informatik.uni-muenchen.de Matthias Hölzl holger#wizards.de Holger Hoffstaette bouvin#daimi.au.dk Niels Olof Bouvin viralbus#daimi.au.dk Thomas Widmann paint007#mc.duke.edu Christopher Painter-Wakefield jtgalkowski#alum.mit.edu Jan Theodore Galkowski pfaffben#msu.edu Ben Pfaff jtbrc#rc.rit.edu Tracy Burdick rick#bcm.tmc.edu Richard H. Miller johnson#cs.uiuc.edu Ralph Johnson rufinus#mbe.ece.wisc.edu J Rufinus xavier.alvarez#emn.fr Xavier Alvarez alexstr#actcom.co.il Alexander Strugatsky brisker#actcom.co.il Tomer Brisker enrico.badella#softstar.it Enrico Badella michele#diee.unica.it Michele Marchesi rkrock#attglobal.net Reg Krock macdonaldrj#att.net Richard MacDonald harry#chomsky.net Harry Chomsky james#foster.net James Foster tbrumley#fuse.net Troy Brumley c.hintze#gmx.net Clemens Hintze fefr#gmx.net Felix Franz J.Podgajny#gmx.net Jaroslaw Podgajny john.link#gmx.net Johannes Link R.Tiefenthal#gmx.net Raymond Tiefenthal nikboyd#jps.net Nik Boyd kneecap#netnet.net Neal Cappel tim#newmarch.net Tim Newmarch</FONT></DIV></BODY></HTML> eliotm#pacbell.net Eliot Miranda daswartz#prodigy.net Douglas A Swartz omar.tejada#prodigy.net Omar Tejada hayes22#swbell.net Chris Hayes ian-news#upright.net Ian Upright ajtibben#home.nl Andre Tibben r.vanette#pink.nl Robert-Jan van Ette rob#sepher.nl Rob Vens Ole-Martin.Halck#ffi.no Ole Martin Halck John_David_Galt#acm.org John David Galt jpelrine#acm.org Joseph Pelrine knight#acm.org Alan Knight pieber#acm.org Bernhard Pieber pmryan#acm.org Patrick M. Ryan rjmct#acm.org Bob Manjoney reinz#Desk.org Reinout Heeck dgroves#emgo.org Don Groves Charlie_Jernigan#gbophb.org Charlie Jernigan bonzini#gnu.org Carlo, Paolo & Germana Craig.Latta#NetJam.ORG Craig Latta steve#serf.org Steve Zara nevin#smalltalk.org Nevin Pratt reichowa#tcfreenet.org Aaron Jon Reichow zen0n#klub.chip.pl Zenobiusz Zimny zaroda#mimuw.edu.pl Artur Zaroda arad#pol.pl Alek Radomski pl#abc.se Per Lang stefant#algonet.se Stefan Tersin janko.mivsek#eranova.si Janko Mivsek dgs#argonet.co.uk dgs chris.uppal#toadskin.demon.co.uk Chris Uppal ian#iandb.ezesurf.co.uk Ian Bartholomew nick#yannakoyorgos.freeserve.co.uk Nicholas Yannakoyorgos john_oshea#wordbank.co.uk John O'Shea Voted NO ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- rurban#sbox.tu-graz.ac.at Reini Urban jlbaker#advbool.com John L. Baker tsattler#avesta.com kimdv#best.com Kim DeVaughn stainles#bga.com Dwight Brown prs#gol.com Peter Stephenson alexis_rzewski#hotmail.com Alexis Rzewski gprrspw#mindspring.com G.P. Ryan olav#viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar sleepy#net1plus.com Alexander Pennace tgm#netcom.com Thomas G. McWilliams jimrtex#pipeline.com Jim Riley RYnchausti#vialink.com Randy A. Ynchausti Abhay.Natu#wcom.com Abhay Natu naddy#mips.inka.de Christian Weisgerber jtuchel#objektfabrik.de Joachim Tuchel nolasco#inx.net Jun Nolasco mmontcha#OregonVOS.net Matthew Montchalin gbloomf#paediatrics.co.nz Guy Bloomfield jeeves#malpeque.org Olav Nieuwejaar jon#thomson2273.freeserve.co.uk Jon Thomson chriseb#ukshells.co.uk Chris Ebenezer Abstained ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- chris#kzim.com Christopher Robin Zimmerman aahz#netcom.com Aahz Invalid ballots ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- reto.fabbri#less.ch Fabbri Reto ! No vote statement in message MJGold#dstsystems.com ! No vote statement in message To restore the email addresses above, pipe the ack list through the following command: sed -e 's/#/@/g' -- Voting question & problems: Dave Cornejo <dave@dogwood.com> Voting address: vote@dogwood.com