TCP Authentication Option Linux implementation (RFC5925)

TCP Authentication Option (TCP-AO) provides a TCP extension aimed at verifying segments between trusted peers. It adds a new TCP header option with a Message Authentication Code (MAC). MACs are produced from the content of a TCP segment using a hashing function with a password known to both peers. The intent of TCP-AO is to deprecate TCP-MD5 providing better security, key rotation and support for variety of hashing algorithms.

1. Introduction

Short and Limited Comparison of TCP-AO and TCP-MD5

TCP-MD5

TCP-AO

Supported hashing algorithms

MD5 (cryptographically weak)

Must support HMAC-SHA1 (chosen-prefix attacks) and CMAC-AES-128 (only side-channel attacks). May support any hashing algorithm.

Length of MACs (bytes)

16

Typically 12-16. Other variants that fit TCP header permitted.

Number of keys per TCP connection

1

Many

Possibility to change an active key

Non-practical (both peers have to change them during MSL)

Supported by protocol

Protection against ICMP ‘hard errors’

No

Yes: ignoring them by default on established connections

Protection against traffic-crossing attack

No

Yes: pseudo-header includes TCP ports.

Protection against replayed TCP segments

No

Sequence Number Extension (SNE) and Initial Sequence Numbers (ISNs)

Supports Connectionless Resets

Yes

No. ISNs+SNE are needed to correctly sign RST.

Standards

RFC 2385

RFC 5925, RFC 5926

1.1 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) with references to RFC 5925

Q: Can either SendID or RecvID be non-unique for the same 4-tuple (srcaddr, srcport, dstaddr, dstport)?

A: No [3.1]:

>> The IDs of MKTs MUST NOT overlap where their TCP connection
identifiers overlap.

Q: Can Master Key Tuple (MKT) for an active connection be removed?

A: No, unless it’s copied to Transport Control Block (TCB) [3.1]:

It is presumed that an MKT affecting a particular connection cannot
be destroyed during an active connection -- or, equivalently, that
its parameters are copied to an area local to the connection (i.e.,
instantiated) and so changes would affect only new connections.

Q: If an old MKT needs to be deleted, how should it be done in order to not remove it for an active connection? (As it can be still in use at any moment later)

A: Not specified by RFC 5925, seems to be a problem for key management to ensure that no one uses such MKT before trying to remove it.

Q: Can an old MKT exist forever and be used by another peer?

A: It can, it’s a key management task to decide when to remove an old key [6.1]:

Deciding when to start using a key is a performance issue. Deciding
when to remove an MKT is a security issue. Invalid MKTs are expected
to be removed. TCP-AO provides no mechanism to coordinate their removal,
as we consider this a key management operation.

also [6.1]:

The only way to avoid reuse of previously used MKTs is to remove the MKT
when it is no longer considered permitted.

Linux TCP-AO will try its best to prevent you from removing a key that’s being used, considering it a key management failure. But since keeping an outdated key may become a security issue and as a peer may unintentionally prevent the removal of an old key by always setting it as RNextKeyID - a forced key removal mechanism is provided, where userspace has to supply KeyID to use instead of the one that’s being removed and the kernel will atomically delete the old key, even if the peer is still requesting it. There are no guarantees for force-delete as the peer may yet not have the new key - the TCP connection may just break. Alternatively, one may choose to shut down the socket.

Q: What happens when a packet is received on a new connection with no known MKT’s RecvID?

A: RFC 5925 specifies that by default it is accepted with a warning logged, but the behaviour can be configured by the user [7.5.1.a]:

If the segment is a SYN, then this is the first segment of a new
connection. Find the matching MKT for this segment, using the segment's
socket pair and its TCP-AO KeyID, matched against the MKT's TCP connection
identifier and the MKT's RecvID.

   i. If there is no matching MKT, remove TCP-AO from the segment.
      Proceed with further TCP handling of the segment.
      NOTE: this presumes that connections that do not match any MKT
      should be silently accepted, as noted in Section 7.3.

[7.3]:

>> A TCP-AO implementation MUST allow for configuration of the behavior
of segments with TCP-AO but that do not match an MKT. The initial default
of this configuration SHOULD be to silently accept such connections.
If this is not the desired case, an MKT can be included to match such
connections, or the connection can indicate that TCP-AO is required.
Alternately, the configuration can be changed to discard segments with
the AO option not matching an MKT.

[10.2.b]:

Connections not matching any MKT do not require TCP-AO. Further, incoming
segments with TCP-AO are not discarded solely because they include
the option, provided they do not match any MKT.

Note that Linux TCP-AO implementation differs in this aspect. Currently, TCP-AO segments with unknown key signatures are discarded with warnings logged.

Q: Does the RFC imply centralized kernel key management in any way? (i.e. that a key on all connections MUST be rotated at the same time?)

A: Not specified. MKTs can be managed in userspace, the only relevant part to key changes is [7.3]:

>> All TCP segments MUST be checked against the set of MKTs for matching
TCP connection identifiers.

Q: What happens when RNextKeyID requested by a peer is unknown? Should the connection be reset?

A: It should not, no action needs to be performed [7.5.2.e]:

ii. If they differ, determine whether the RNextKeyID MKT is ready.

    1. If the MKT corresponding to the segment’s socket pair and RNextKeyID
    is not available, no action is required (RNextKeyID of a received
    segment needs to match the MKT’s SendID).

Q: How current_key is set and when does it change? It is a user-triggered change, or is it by a request from the remote peer? Is it set by the user explicitly, or by a matching rule?

A: current_key is set by RNextKeyID [6.1]:

Rnext_key is changed only by manual user intervention or MKT management
protocol operation. It is not manipulated by TCP-AO. Current_key is updated
by TCP-AO when processing received TCP segments as discussed in the segment
processing description in Section 7.5. Note that the algorithm allows
the current_key to change to a new MKT, then change back to a previously
used MKT (known as "backing up"). This can occur during an MKT change when
segments are received out of order, and is considered a feature of TCP-AO,
because reordering does not result in drops.

[7.5.2.e.ii]:

2. If the matching MKT corresponding to the segment’s socket pair and
RNextKeyID is available:

   a. Set current_key to the RNextKeyID MKT.

Q: If both peers have multiple MKTs matching the connection’s socket pair (with different KeyIDs), how should the sender/receiver pick KeyID to use?

A: Some mechanism should pick the “desired” MKT [3.3]:

Multiple MKTs may match a single outgoing segment, e.g., when MKTs
are being changed. Those MKTs cannot have conflicting IDs (as noted
elsewhere), and some mechanism must determine which MKT to use for each
given outgoing segment.

>> An outgoing TCP segment MUST match at most one desired MKT, indicated
by the segment’s socket pair. The segment MAY match multiple MKTs, provided
that exactly one MKT is indicated as desired. Other information in
the segment MAY be used to determine the desired MKT when multiple MKTs
match; such information MUST NOT include values in any TCP option fields.

Q: Can TCP-MD5 connection migrate to TCP-AO (and vice-versa):

A: No [1]:

TCP MD5-protected connections cannot be migrated to TCP-AO because TCP MD5
does not support any changes to a connection’s security algorithm
once established.

Q: If all MKTs are removed on a connection, can it become a non-TCP-AO signed connection?

A: [7.5.2] doesn’t have the same choice as SYN packet handling in [7.5.1.i] that would allow accepting segments without a sign (which would be insecure). While switching to non-TCP-AO connection is not prohibited directly, it seems what the RFC means. Also, there’s a requirement for TCP-AO connections to always have one current_key [3.3]:

TCP-AO requires that every protected TCP segment match exactly one MKT.

[3.3]:

>> An incoming TCP segment including TCP-AO MUST match exactly one MKT,
indicated solely by the segment’s socket pair and its TCP-AO KeyID.

[4.4]:

One or more MKTs. These are the MKTs that match this connection’s
socket pair.

Q: Can a non-TCP-AO connection become a TCP-AO-enabled one?

A: No: for already established non-TCP-AO connection it would be impossible to switch using TCP-AO as the traffic key generation requires the initial sequence numbers. Paraphrasing, starting using TCP-AO would require re-establishing the TCP connection.

2. In-kernel MKTs database vs database in userspace

Linux TCP-AO support is implemented using setsockopt()s, in a similar way to TCP-MD5. It means that a userspace application that wants to use TCP-AO should perform setsockopt() on a TCP socket when it wants to add, remove or rotate MKTs. This approach moves the key management responsibility to userspace as well as decisions on corner cases, i.e. what to do if the peer doesn’t respect RNextKeyID; moving more code to userspace, especially responsible for the policy decisions. Besides, it’s flexible and scales well (with less locking needed than in the case of an in-kernel database). One also should keep in mind that mainly intended users are BGP processes, not any random applications, which means that compared to IPsec tunnels, no transparency is really needed and modern BGP daemons already have setsockopt()s for TCP-MD5 support.

Considered pros and cons of the approaches

setsockopt()

in-kernel DB

Extendability

setsockopt() commands should be extendable syscalls

Netlink messages are simple and extendable

Required userspace changes

BGP or any application that wants TCP-AO needs to perform setsockopt()s and do key management

could be transparent as tunnels, providing something like ip tcpao add key (delete/show/rotate)

MKTs removal or adding

harder for userspace

harder for kernel

Dump-ability

getsockopt()

Netlink .dump() callback

Limits on kernel resources/memory

equal

Scalability

contention on TCP_LISTEN sockets

contention on the whole database

Monitoring & warnings

TCP_DIAG

same Netlink socket

Matching of MKTs

half-problem: only listen sockets

hard

3. uAPI

Linux provides a set of setsockopt()s and getsockopt()s that let userspace manage TCP-AO on a per-socket basis. In order to add/delete MKTs TCP_AO_ADD_KEY and TCP_AO_DEL_KEY TCP socket options must be used It is not allowed to add a key on an established non-TCP-AO connection as well as to remove the last key from TCP-AO connection.

setsockopt(TCP_AO_DEL_KEY) command may specify tcp_ao_del::current_key + tcp_ao_del::set_current and/or tcp_ao_del::rnext + tcp_ao_del::set_rnext which makes such delete “forced”: it provides userspace a way to delete a key that’s being used and atomically set another one instead. This is not intended for normal use and should be used only when the peer ignores RNextKeyID and keeps requesting/using an old key. It provides a way to force-delete a key that’s not trusted but may break the TCP-AO connection.

The usual/normal key-rotation can be performed with setsockopt(TCP_AO_INFO). It also provides a uAPI to change per-socket TCP-AO settings, such as ignoring ICMPs, as well as clear per-socket TCP-AO packet counters. The corresponding getsockopt(TCP_AO_INFO) can be used to get those per-socket TCP-AO settings.

Another useful command is getsockopt(TCP_AO_GET_KEYS). One can use it to list all MKTs on a TCP socket or use a filter to get keys for a specific peer and/or sndid/rcvid, VRF L3 interface or get current_key/rnext_key.

To repair TCP-AO connections setsockopt(TCP_AO_REPAIR) is available, provided that the user previously has checkpointed/dumped the socket with getsockopt(TCP_AO_REPAIR).

A tip here for scaled TCP_LISTEN sockets, that may have some thousands TCP-AO keys, is: use filters in getsockopt(TCP_AO_GET_KEYS) and asynchronous delete with setsockopt(TCP_AO_DEL_KEY).

Linux TCP-AO also provides a bunch of segment counters that can be helpful with troubleshooting/debugging issues. Every MKT has good/bad counters that reflect how many packets passed/failed verification. Each TCP-AO socket has the following counters: - for good segments (properly signed) - for bad segments (failed TCP-AO verification) - for segments with unknown keys - for segments where an AO signature was expected, but wasn’t found - for the number of ignored ICMPs

TCP-AO per-socket counters are also duplicated with per-netns counters, exposed with SNMP. Those are TCPAOGood, TCPAOBad, TCPAOKeyNotFound, TCPAORequired and TCPAODroppedIcmps.

RFC 5925 very permissively specifies how TCP port matching can be done for MKTs:

TCP connection identifier. A TCP socket pair, i.e., a local IP
address, a remote IP address, a TCP local port, and a TCP remote port.
Values can be partially specified using ranges (e.g., 2-30), masks
(e.g., 0xF0), wildcards (e.g., "*"), or any other suitable indication.

Currently Linux TCP-AO implementation doesn’t provide any TCP port matching. Probably, port ranges are the most flexible for uAPI, but so far not implemented.

4. setsockopt() vs accept() race

In contrast with TCP-MD5 established connection which has just one key, TCP-AO connections may have many keys, which means that accepted connections on a listen socket may have any amount of keys as well. As copying all those keys on a first properly signed SYN would make the request socket bigger, that would be undesirable. Currently, the implementation doesn’t copy keys to request sockets, but rather look them up on the “parent” listener socket.

The result is that when userspace removes TCP-AO keys, that may break not-yet-established connections on request sockets as well as not removing keys from sockets that were already established, but not yet accept()’ed, hanging in the accept queue.

The reverse is valid as well: if userspace adds a new key for a peer on a listener socket, the established sockets in accept queue won’t have the new keys.

At this moment, the resolution for the two races: setsockopt(TCP_AO_ADD_KEY) vs accept() and setsockopt(TCP_AO_DEL_KEY) vs accept() is delegated to userspace. This means that it’s expected that userspace would check the MKTs on the socket that was returned by accept() to verify that any key rotation that happened on listen socket is reflected on the newly established connection.

This is a similar “do-nothing” approach to TCP-MD5 from the kernel side and may be changed later by introducing new flags to tcp_ao_add and tcp_ao_del.

Note that this race is rare for it needs TCP-AO key rotation to happen during the 3-way handshake for the new TCP connection.

5. Interaction with TCP-MD5

A TCP connection can not migrate between TCP-AO and TCP-MD5 options. The established sockets that have either AO or MD5 keys are restricted for adding keys of the other option.

For listening sockets the picture is different: BGP server may want to receive both TCP-AO and (deprecated) TCP-MD5 clients. As a result, both types of keys may be added to TCP_CLOSED or TCP_LISTEN sockets. It’s not allowed to add different types of keys for the same peer.

6. SNE Linux implementation

RFC 5925 [6.2] describes the algorithm of how to extend TCP sequence numbers with SNE. In short: TCP has to track the previous sequence numbers and set sne_flag when the current SEQ number rolls over. The flag is cleared when both current and previous SEQ numbers cross 0x7fff, which is 32Kb.

In times when sne_flag is set, the algorithm compares SEQ for each packet with 0x7fff and if it’s higher than 32Kb, it assumes that the packet should be verified with SNE before the increment. As a result, there’s this [0; 32Kb] window, when packets with (SNE - 1) can be accepted.

Linux implementation simplifies this a bit: as the network stack already tracks the first SEQ byte that ACK is wanted for (snd_una) and the next SEQ byte that is wanted (rcv_nxt) - that’s enough information for a rough estimation on where in the 4GB SEQ number space both sender and receiver are. When they roll over to zero, the corresponding SNE gets incremented.

tcp_ao_compute_sne() is called for each TCP-AO segment. It compares SEQ numbers from the segment with snd_una or rcv_nxt and fits the result into a 2GB window around them, detecting SEQ numbers rolling over. That simplifies the code a lot and only requires SNE numbers to be stored on every TCP-AO socket.

The 2GB window at first glance seems much more permissive compared to RFC 5926. But that is only used to pick the correct SNE before/after a rollover. It allows more TCP segment replays, but yet all regular TCP checks in tcp_sequence() are applied on the verified segment. So, it trades a bit more permissive acceptance of replayed/retransmitted segments for the simplicity of the algorithm and what seems better behaviour for large TCP windows.